Some assume that all spatulas are the same, but we know better, don’t we? The spatula you use to saute vegetables is very different from the spatula you use to get cookies off the baking sheet. That said, what is the best cookie spatula?
Well, there are a ton of spatulas on the market, but a lot of them seem to be designed to be sold to people who don’t know the difference between flippers, spreaders, and scrapers. We do. And today we’re looking at cookie spatulas. But before we get into tips, tricks, and considerations, let’s take a look at some popular options.
The Oxo Good Grips Silicone Cookie Spatula is made from high-quality materials and designed with the perfect angled stainless steel handle and non-scratch silicone head, making it the best of all worlds when it comes to cookie spatulas.
When budget is an issue, Mrs. Anderson’s Serving Spatula takes the cake (or cookie) with its stylish wooden handle and narrow stainless steel head, perfect for handling cookies, serving, and is a steal for the amount you’ll pay.
Quick Comparison: Top 10 Best Cookie Spatulas
1. OXO Good Grips Silicone Cookie Spatula
For starters, we have the Oxo Good Grips Silicone Cookie Spatula. It’s simple, effective, and the ideal size for lifting cookies off of a baking sheet. It’s made out of silicone that is bonded to a stainless steel handle angled to keep your hands out of the food, while the silicone is there to prevent sticking and won’t scrape your cookie sheets. For this reason, it’s perfect for removing and lifting cookies freshly baked right out of the oven.
It’s just the right size at 9.2 by 2.6 inches. Plus, it has one rounded corner, and another squared off one to handle various cookie situations. For instance, the rounded corner can be used to scrape the dough out of a spoon, while the squared corner is ideal for sliding under a freshly baked cookie for lifting.
What else? It’s flexible, durable, and comfortable to grip. It’s also heat resistant up to 600 degrees Fahrenheit and dishwasher safe. Overall, the Oxo Cookie Spatula stands out as a well-made and well-designed kitchen implement. It’s excellent for anyone who loves to bake cookies, especially if you like to sample one fresh out of the oven.
2. Mrs. Anderson's Baking Cookie Dessert Serving Spatula
Another great cookie spatula we found is Mrs. Anderson’s Serving Spatula. It’s a long and narrow spatula with a wooden handle and beveled edges ideal for lifting cookies from the baking sheet to a cooling rack.
That said, Mrs. Anderson’s Spatula is a lot more versatile than the Oxo one mentioned above. It’s designed for cutting, scraping, and serving all different kinds of deserts. In addition to cookies, you can use it for brownies, bars, cake, fudge; you name it.
What we really like is its size. It fits nicely in your hand and is narrow enough to slide under and pick up small cookies, like those ready to bake ones you can get at the store. It’s strong and flexible. It should last you a long time.
It’s made out of stainless steel, so it’s versatile, but you have to be careful not to scrap your baking sheets and pans. It has a stylish wooden grip, which is nice, but you will have to wash it by hand so that the wood doesn’t become damaged and swell in the dishwasher or sink.
3. Fox Run Large Oversized Stainless Steel Cookie Spatula
Did someone say giant cookies? The Fox Run Cookie Spatula is just the tool you need. While Mrs. Anderson’s spatula is excellent for small desserts, when it comes to large or “oversized” cookies, this Fox Run spatula has the size to handle just about anything.
What makes the Fox Run spatula stand out is its beveled edge with rounded sides designed for picking up circular foods. All told, it’s over one foot across, making it perfect for large cookies, but you can also use it for pancakes, cake, and even mini pizzas.
Overall, it’s simple and sturdy, made from stainless steel with a pom handle. It also has a metal loop at the end for hanging it up if you like to do that. It’s built to last and should be a tool you have in your kitchen for years to come.Its beveled edge makes it easy to slide under cookies, even if they’re still hot and right out of the oven. Plus, its handle is angled just right for control and convenience. It’s designed specifically for large cookies, which are real winners when it comes to bake sales and fundraisers.
4. Fox Run Cookie/Brownie Spatula
Another spatula from Fox Run, this one is much smaller but still a good bet for cookies and brownies. The entire implement is 7 inches long, with the spatula head itself being a narrow 1-inch width and 2.25 inches long.
Like the oversized Fox Run spatula, this one is made from sturdy stainless steel, but this time it has a wooden handle, which has its pluses and minuses. On the one hand, wood offers a stylish, steady, and dependable grip, but, on the other, it’s not dishwasher safe, so you’ll have to clean this one by hand.
Nevertheless, if you’re looking for a small spatula with a lot of versatility, this one is a good pick. It has a beveled edge for sliding under cookies and lifting them from the baking sheet to a cooling rack (or your mouth). It’s wide enough to hold and prevent your baked goods from crumbling and falling apart.Plus, its built to last. It has a nice curve to it, and it’s built for heavy-duty cookie lifting. All in all, this Fox Run spatula is bound to be one of your favorites for cookies and other baked goods (like brownies). This spatula is budget-friendly and something that you’ll have in your kitchen for many years.
5. Home Hero Solid Turner Silicone Spatula
The Home Hero Solid Turner spatula is genuinely a good buy for your money. It’s made for non-stick pans from silicone that won’t scrap your cookie sheets. That said, it’s a good size for cookies and has a beveled edge for sliding under them and lifting them to your cooling rack.
This spatula has a wooden handle crafted from acacia wood, with a nice smooth feel, color, and pattern, plus a hole drilled in the end for hanging it up and storage. Home Hero claims it’s built to last 40 years if you take care of it. While we don’t know about that, it is sturdy, and the wood offers an elegant appearance.
For a silicone spatula, it’s durable and high-quality. It’s also dishwasher safe and convenient to have around. On top of that, it’s safe and is not likely to get too hot and burn you, while its silicone material can withstand heat of up to 392 degrees Fahrenheit before you start to have any problems.Overall, what we really like about the Home Hero Silicone Spatula is that you don’t have to worry about scratching your baking sheets. Even if you’re careless, or the kids get involved, it won’t damage your expensive pots, pans, and baking sheets.
6. DI ORO Designer Series Flexible Small Silicone Turner Spatula
While the Home Hero spatula is nice, this spatula from DI ORO is built to withstand the heat. It’s made from a rubber silicone material that can withstand up to 600 degrees Fahrenheit. So, you won’t have to worry about this one melting on the side of a pan and getting plastic in your food.
The DI ORO spatula has a silicone head, as we mentioned, but it also features a handle made from the same material. It’s simple but has a nice feel in your hand. And on top of that, it is built around a flexible but durable stainless steel core.
The great thing about this spatula is that it’s not only perfect for non-stick pans but also able to slide under and pick up cookies with ease. It has a beveled edge and, much like the Oxo spatula, has one rounded corner for scraping dough out of a spoon or for handling delicate cookies so that they won’t fall apart when you go to pick them up.All in all, the reason the DI ORO spatula stands out is because of its durability and usefulness. Sure, it’s great for cookies, but you can also use it for other things. The silicone won’t scratch your expensive cookware, and it’s constructed from high-quality material meant to last for years.
7. Wilton The Really Big Spatula
Sometimes, you don’t want to have to lift each cookie one at a time. Believe it or not, you don’t have to. The Wilton spatula is huge. Under size, it’s listed as “mega” and for a good reason. The Wilton spatula is over 6 inches across, about the same width as a small baking sheet. It’s designed to be able to lift six cookies at once. It has a nice flat head for picking up cookies and really can scoop six 1-inch cookies at the same time or lift one monster cookie if you’re into that.
Its head is made from silicone, and it has a stainless steel handle. The silicone makes the Wilton great for non-stick pans, and the steel keeps it durable. All in all, it’s really well made.
Really, what makes the Wilton spatula stand out is its size. If you’re into baking a lot of cookies at once or are looking for a way to increase your efficiency while you bake in bulk, this spatula is for you. That said, it is a quality constructed spatula that won’t scratch your expensive cookware.
8. Ateco Cookie Spatula
The Ateco Cookie Spatula is described as a blade rather than a standard spatula head. In other words, it’s made of very thin metal that is perfect for sliding under cookies even when they’re still hot and crumbly. Suppose you prefer metal over silicone, then this spatula is a good bet for handling cookies. Its bladed head is dishwasher safe, while its handle is durable plastic. It’s available in a number of different sizes, but we’ve found that 2.5” is about right for lifting cookies from the baking sheet to a drying rack.
The Ateco Cookie Spatula is simple, and sometimes simple is best. It’s professional quality and easy to clean and work with. What’s more, its thin, bladed head can be used for cutting and serving desserts. This spatula from Ateco stands out because of its general usability. Its smooth handle feels nice in your hands, and its thin, metal head is perfect for lifting cookies. It’s well constructed and a great buy for its cost.
9. KitchenAid Gourmet Cookie Lifter
Another sleek and simple cookie spatula is the KitchenAid Gourmet Cookie Lifter. KitchenAid is a brand many of us trust for quality kitchen implements, and this spatula is no exception. It has a durable, nylon head with flat edges that are ideal for sliding under cookies. Its handle is ergonomic and fits perfectly in your hand with a nice weight and balance. It has a chrome-plated bolster and a stainless steel end cap.
On top of that, the KitchenAid Gourmet Cookie Lifter is dishwasher safe, which makes cleanup simple. It’s durable and won’t scratch your cooking sheets. We love the design of this spatula. It’s very nicely balanced, which feels substantial in your hand. Its black and silver look is sleek, and it’s built for comfort and control.
10. Bakelicious Nylon Cookie Spatula
We love the look of this one. The Bakelicious Cookie Spatula is designed just for cookies and is a fun purple nylon spatula. It’s lightweight and works beautifully for lifting cookies from a baking sheet to a drying rack, plate, or straight into your mouth.
It’s a small spatula, making it easy to hold, handle, and store. It’s durable and dishwasher safe. The word “cookie” is even embossed into the spatula’s surface. All in all, the Bakelicious spatula is well made and budget-friendly. It’s a fun way to add some color to your cooking experience. Plus, it’s easy to clean.
The Bakelicious Nylon Cookie Spatula is sure to stand out amongst all other implements in your kitchen. Its color alone is enough to brighten your day, and its functionality is on point.
Things to Consider When Buying a Cookie Spatula
There are a number of things to consider when looking for the best cookie spatula. For some, the price may be the biggest issue, while it’s more about size or quality for others. Whatever the case may be, here are a few things to consider when buying a cookie spatula.
How to Choose a Cookie Spatula
While personal style and preference are certainly factors, it’s critical that you choose a spatula that’s right for handling cookies. Look for high-quality materials, such as stainless steel. When considering a silicone spatula, check that it is heat resistant, generally a sign of a good spatula.
As for choosing between metal and silicone, it depends on the types of baking sheets you’re using. If you have non-stick baking sheets, a silicone spatula may be best to prevent scratching. Still, many prefer stainless steel for its durability and thinness.
Other things to watch out for is the angle of the handle. Often, a straight handle with no bend to it is a sign of a cheaply-made spatula. Also, look carefully at how the head of the spatula is bonded to the handle. The last thing you need in a spatula is for it to break.
Why You Should Use a Cookie Spatula
Some might be wondering why using a cookie spatula is so essential. Why not use one of the regular spatulas you already have at home? Sure, a regular spatula might work, but they tend not to be thin enough to properly slide under cookies.
For this reason, many people wait until their cookies are cool before they remove them from the pan. This takes time, and you may want to re-use your cookie sheet for the next batch. Fortunately, a cookie spatula is designed to slide under cookies, even when they are still warm and gooey, and lift them without breaking apart.
So, you should use a cookie spatula to ensure you make the best cookies. Being able to remove your freshly baked cookies from the baking sheet right away prevents the cookies from continuing to cook on the hot pan, keeping them moist and delicious.
How to Use a Cookie Spatula
There are a couple of different ways you can use a cookie spatula properly. For lifting cookies from a forward position, grip the spatula in one hand with your thumb on top. Lineup the flat edge so that it is parallel to the baking sheet and slide it slowly under the cookie.
You can also use the spatula from the side. To do this, grip the handle with your thumb on the bottom, and your knuckles lined up in a straight line with the spatula. Again, place the spatula's flat end down parallel to the baking sheet and slide it under the cookie.
It’s crucial to start slow in case the cookie is stuck to the baking sheet. Going too fast can break the cookie or tear it in half. It also sometimes helps to move the spatula in and out until you can get the entire cookie on it.
Which Is Better - Stainless Steel or Silicone?
Although we touched on this a little already, you may have noticed that about half of the spatulas we recommend are stainless steel, and the other half are silicone or nylon equivalent. That’s mainly because some people like silicone and others like metal.
However, it’s essential to realize that silicone is a gentler and safer material in general. It won’t scratch your pans, and it doesn’t get super hot, so it won’t burn you. Some steel spatulas are also thin enough to cut skin, which is something to watch out for.
That said, many people still prefer stainless steel over silicone because of its durability and longevity. It takes a very long time for steel to wear out, and it handles cookies really well. While silicone is heat resistant, stainless steel is basically heatproof.
Are ALL Silicone Spatulas Considered Heat Resistant
To add to the stainless steel versus silicone debate, most silicone spatulas are heat resistant. Some on the market are cheaply made and could melt if exposed to heat, so it’s a good idea to be wary. Still, most can withstand high heats, and you should be okay.
For example, if you look at the silicone spatulas we’ve featured in this article, you’ll see that each one includes a maximum safe temperature for them. If a silicone spatula doesn’t explicitly state its heat resistance and temperature, you may want to pass on that one.
Next time you’re baking cookies, think about the spatula you’re using. Is it really the best cookie spatula for the job? Are you using a saute spatula that’s going to scratch your expensive cookie sheets? Do you have a spatula that’s large enough to lift your delicious “oversized” cookies?
Cookie spatulas are explicitly designed for sliding under cookies and transferring them from the baking sheet to a drying rack or plate. Some of them are made from stainless steel, while others offer a silicone or nylon head for protecting non-stick pans.
At the end of the day, the spatula you prefer for handling cookies comes down to your style and the features you find most important. Who knows, your next favorite spatula may be on this list.