Do you love pizzas, be it homemade or store-bought? Do you, too, struggle to achieve that crispy and golden crust when making pizzas at home? Most of us end up with soggy and chewy pizza when we try to make it at home. But what if we told you that it is not your fault?
Not using the right pizza pan will keep you from making quality pizzas. You will see a change in the flavour and texture of your pizza once you start using the best pizza pans. You will not want to buy pizzas from pizzerias any longer. You and your guests will be amazed by how good your homemade pizza tastes, all thanks to the high-quality and durable pizza pans.
Best Pick
The Lodge Pizza Pan is our best pick because of its solid cast-iron construction, ability to retain a high temperature and convenient features such as the sturdy handles and the pre-seasoned cooking surface. The Lodge Pizza Pan is a multifunctional pan that allows for flexible cooking. You will not be disappointed by its impeccable performance.
Budget Pick
The American Metalcraft Pizza Pan is our budget pick because of its low weight, high-quality aluminium material and convenient size. The American Metalcraft Pizza Pan is easy to use and maintain. The 9-inch pan is definitely worth the price.
Quick Comparison: The 12 Best Pizza Pans
| Product Name | Shape | Item Diameter/Cooking Area (inches) | Material | Weight (pounds) | Item Dimensions (inches) | Grade |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Lodge Pizza Pan | Round | 12 | Cast Iron | 9.53 | 18.43 x 14.75 x 1.25 | A |
| American Metalcraft Pizza Pan | Round | 9 | Aluminium | 0.23 | 9.25 x 9.25 x 0.38 | A |
| Cuisinart Chef's Pizza Pan | Round | 14 | Stainless Steel | 1.14 | 15 x 14.4 x 1 | B |
| Wilton Pizza Pan | Round | 14 | Steel | 1.19 | 14.1 x 0.36 x 14.1 | A |
| Cuisinel Pre-Seasoned Cast Iron Pizza | Round | 13.5 | Cast Iron | 7.30 | 13 x 15 x 1 | B |
| Heritage Pizza Pan | Round | 15 | Ceramic | 3.15 | 15.79 x 15.79 x 2.48 | A |
| Home-Complete Cast Iron Pizza Pan | Round | 14 | Cast Iron | 6.60 | 13.5 x 17 x 1.5 | B |
| Chicago Metallic Pizza Pan | Round | 14 | Steel | 1.85 | 14 x 14 x 1.5 | A |
| G&S Metal Products Company Pizza Pan | Round | 12 | Steel | 0.73 | 12 x 0.25 x 12 | A |
| LloydPans Kitchenware Pizza Pan | Square | 80 | Hard-Anodized Aluminum | 0.90 | 8 x 10 x 2.25 | A |
| Legend Cast Iron Pizza Pan | Round | 14 | Alloy Steel | 8.93 | 15.75 x 15.5 x 1.6 | A |
| Beasea Pizza Pan | Round | 8.5 | Aluminium | 0.36 | 9.7 x 8.5 x 1.1 | B |
1. Lodge Pizza Pan
If you love pizza and want to make professional-grade pizzas at home, the Lodge Pizza Pan might be the one for you. The Lodge Pizza Pan is a 14-inch round pan that can be used in the oven, stovetop, grill or even over a campfire.
The Lodge Pizza Pan is one of the best pizza pans in the market because you can not only use it to make pizza but you can also sear meat, broil fish, fry bacon or even grill corn. This multi-functional baking pan can give your homemade pizza the restaurant-worthy texture and flavours.
The Lodge Pizza Pan has a cast-iron construction that makes it more durable. The pizza pan has a high heat tolerance that enables you to use it on various cooktops. The cast-iron construction retains and distributes heat well throughout the pizza pan. Hot or cold spots are reduced which helps to cook your pizza evenly.
The Lodge Pizza Pan comes pre-seasoned which means that you can start making pizza right away. You do not need to season the pizza pan which can be a lengthy process. Since the pizza pan is already pre-seasoned, it does not rust easily. This makes storing it much easier.
The pizza pan is super easy to clean as well. All you need to do is wash the pan with mild soap and rinse it well with water. If you do not have mild soap, it is recommended to not use any since harsh detergents may wear out the cast-iron coating. You need to dry the pan completely and coat it with a little oil before storing it away. To prevent the pan from rusting, it is recommended to store the pan in a dry and cool place.
Pros
Cons
2. American Metalcraft Pizza Pan
The American Metalcraft Pizza Pan is extremely lightweight, has a durable construction and does not fail to deliver great performance. It has a diameter of 9 inches which is great for making a pizza that is large enough for a few friends.
The American Metalcraft Pizza Pan has heavy-duty 18-gauge aluminium construction. This enables the pizza pan to retain high temperatures for longer periods of time. The flat bottom with raised edges aid in distributing heat evenly throughout the pan.
Your pizza is most likely to cook evenly and will not turn out to be soggy or burnt. Plus, the high-quality material gives the pizza pan a durable finish that enables it to withstand harsh conditions, meaning that it does not become worn out quickly.
The pan weighs only 0.23 pounds which means that you will be able to carry the pan in one hand easily. The low weight of the pizza pan makes it easier to take it out of the oven. Since the pizza pan has a high heat tolerance, it does not warp easily when exposed to a high temperature.
The American Metalcraft Pizza Pan is super easy to clean. You can soak it in hot water so that the hardened remains of food soften. This will make it easier to scrub them off. You might want to use a mild soap or dish detergent when washing the pan. The pizza pan might not be safe to be put into the dishwasher as the pan might react with harsh dish detergents. This will cause the pizza pan to tarnish soon.
Pros
Cons
3. Cuisinart Chef's Pizza Pan
If you are having trouble trying to get the perfect dough texture, you might want to check the Cuisinart Chef’s Pizza Pan. The pizza pan has tiny holes all around the surface which makes it easier to cook your pizza evenly.
Plus, the Cuisinart Chef’s Pizza Pan has a diameter of 14 inches so you can easily make a large pizza for your friends and family. The large shape makes this pan great for parties.
The Cuisinart Chef’s Pizza Pan has a heavy gauge aluminized steel construction. This makes the pizza pan retain heat better and for a longer period of time. Your pizza pan will remain hot for quite some time even after you are done with the cooking. The heat spreads out evenly across the pan and reaches your pizza dough from all sides. You are unlikely to have undercooked or overcooked pizza.
The pizza pan has a Whitford Xylan non-stick coating on the surface which prevents the dough from sticking to it. You can easily transfer the pizza onto another dish to cut it into slices. Plus, the non-stick coating makes cleaning easier as you do not need to scrub off the hardened bits of food which can be a time-consuming process.
Pros
Cons
4. Wilton Pizza Pan
You can make delicious pizzas using the 14-inch Wilton Pizza Pan. The large pizza pan is ideal for making homemade pizzas or even store-bought pizzas. Plus, it has a non-stick surface so you do not have to worry about scrapping the pizza off of the pan after it is cooked.
The Wilton Pizza Pan is made of steel which makes the pan more durable. Steel is known to be a good conductor of heat and the flat bottom will help to spread the heat evenly across the pizza pan. The steel construction will not react with acidic food. The flavour of your pizza will not be altered.
The non-stick coating is made of silicone polyester and it does not release any odours when exposed to high temperatures. Plus the non-stick coating prevents the Wilton Pizza Pan from rusting or corroding. The edges of the pizza pan are slightly raised to produce crispy crusts and also to prevent the pan from warping.
The pizza pan is safe to be put in a dishwasher which makes cleaning the pan a lot simpler. The pizza pan is easy to clean by hand as well. The crumbs and stains wash off easily and you do not need to use any special dish detergent to clean it. You can not only make pizzas but you can also use the pan to roast vegetables or make nachos.
Pros
Cons
5. Cuisinel Pre-Seasoned Cast Iron Pizza
The Cuisinel Pizza Pan can be used for a variety of purposes. You can use the pizza pan to make deep-dish pizzas, roast potatoes, burger patties or even desserts such as cookies and biscuits. The Cuisinel Pizza Pan is safe to use on induction cooktops, stovetops and even on grills. The pan is also great for searing, sauteing or even broiling.
The cast iron pizza pan has a total diameter of 13.5 inches. Without the raised ridges, the diameter of the pizza pan is 12 inches. It has a depth of 1 inch which makes it ideal for making deep dishes.
The spacious pizza pan comes with two handles that are each 1.5 inches. The handles are large enough for you to have a good grip on the pan, even while wearing oven mitts or potholders.
The Cuisinel Pizza Pan has a cast iron construction that helps to retain a high temperature well. Plus the pizza pan has a flat bottom which helps to distribute heat evenly across the cooking surface. This means that your food will cook evenly and within the set time. Your food will turn out to be crispy and flavourful.
Although the large pizza pan comes pre-seasoned, you still need to season it before using it for the first time. You will need to coat the pan with oil and put in the oven at a high temperature. You can also use butter for this step. Moreover, the cast iron gets better each time you season the pan. This means that the pan is long-lasting and will perform well for several years.
It is super easy to clean the Cusinel Pizza Pan. all you need to do is wash it with warm water. It is recommended to not use any soap or dish detergent when cleaning the pizza pan. Make sure to completely dry the pan and lightly coat it with oil before storing it away. To prevent the pan from rusting, it is advised to store it in a dry and cool place.
Pros
Cons
6. Heritage Pizza Pan
The Heritage Pizza Pan is a spacious, ceramic pizza pan that has a diameter of 15 inches. You can easily make a large pizza for a party. Plus, this pizza pan is super easy to maintain. The Heritage pizza pan is a convenient and durable piece of bakeware that will serve you well for many years to come.
The Heritage Pizza Pan has a black ceramic construction which means that pan is unlikely to have any problem with retaining and distributing heat across the cooking area. The ceramic pizza pan has a high heat tolerance so it will not break or crack when exposed to high heat.
The flat base aids in distributing heat across the pan evenly. There are unlikely to be hot or cold spots on the pan so your pizza will cook properly. Plus, your pizza may take less time to cook as the ceramic pan heats up quickly.
The spacious pizza pan has a non-stick coating that prevents the dough from sticking to the surface of the pan. This makes cleaning easier as you do not need to scrub off the hardened remains of food from the pan. Plus, it is super easy to get rid of stains from grease or burnt crusts. To wash the pizza pan, you can take a soft sponge and warm soapy water and your pan will look good as new again.
Pros
Cons
7. Home-Complete Cast Iron Pizza Pan
If you are looking for a multifunctional pizza pan, then you might be interested in knowing more about the Home-Complete Pizza Pan. This pizza pan not only lets you make golden crust pizzas, but it also allows you to grill, bake, broil, sear or even fry vegetables and meat. You can easily cook a lot of food using this 14-inch Home-Complete Pizza Pan.
The pizza pan has a cast-iron construction that makes it retain heat well. The cast iron also helps to spread out heat evenly across the cooking surface. Hot spots are likely to be minimised which means that your pizza will not have burnt crusts anymore. The Home-Complete Pizza Pan comes seasoned so you do not need to worry about the pan rusting any time soon.
Since the pizza pan comes seasoned, you can start making pizzas as soon as it arrives. The large pizza pan is seasoned with vegetable oil and does not contain any toxic chemicals. Moreover, the pizza pan has raised ridges that prevent it from warping. Plus, the raised ridges allow you to achieve the perfect, crispy crusts.
The Home-Complete Pizza Pan is safe to use on the grill and stovetops. You can also use it on induction cooktops. The flat bottom of the pan makes it easy to place the pan on any type of burner. On the other hand, the pizza pan is extremely easy to clean. It is recommended to wash the pizza pan with warm water and mild soap. You might want to coat it with oil before storing it in a cool and dry place.
Pros
Cons
8. Chicago Metallic Pizza Pan
If you are fond of Chicago-style pizzas, the Chicago Metallic Pizza Pan might fulfil your desire to make such pizzas at home. The Chicago Metallic Pizza Pan has a depth of 1.5 inches. This means that you can cook meals other than just deep-dish pizzas. You can bake a pie or even make nachos using this pizza pan.
The heavy-duty carbon steel construction allows the pizza pan to serve you well for several years. Pans that have a carbon steel construction are known to brown foods better. Such pans heat up quickly and retain heat for longer periods of time. Plus, the carbon steel construction provides a smooth surface which makes it easier to cook delicate food.
The Chicago Metallic Pizza Pan has a silicone-based non-stick coating that prevents food from sticking to the surface of the pizza pan. It also makes cleaning the pan easier as you do not need to spend hours trying to scrub off the hardened crumbs of food. Since the pizza pan is safe to be used in the dishwasher, you can relax and enjoy your food as you do not need to worry about doing the dishes.
The pizza pan is super lightweight. It weighs only 1.85 pounds which means that you can carry it easily around your kitchen. The pan is oven-safe to up to 450 degrees Fahrenheit and is not meant to be used in the broiler.
Pros
Cons
9. G&S Metal Products Company Pizza Pan
The pizza pan from G&S Metal Products Company is a flat, non-stick pan that you can use to make restaurant-worthy pizzas. The pizza pan is extremely lightweight. It weighs only 0.73 pounds which means that you can easily carry it around, even when it has a large pizza on top.
The pizza pan has a smooth surface and the non-stick coating is made with Teflon. This makes it easier to transfer the pizza onto another dish as the pizza will slide off smoothly. It is recommended to use wooden, plastic or silicone utensils when using the pizza pan. This is because metal utensils or sharp objects will ruin the non-stick coating.
The G&S Metal Products Company Pizza Pan has a heavy-duty steel construction that enables it to retain heat well. It also enables the pan to distribute heat evenly across the cooking surface. Plus, the flat base sits well on the oven racks. The 12-inch pizza pan has raised ridges that allow the pizza to stay in place. The raised ridges also help when you are taking the pan out of the oven as you can hold them for support.
The non-stick Teflon coating makes cleaning the pizza pan easier as the crumbs and hardened bits of food wash off easily. Grease and stains from sauces also wash off easily. If you want, you can put the pizza pan in a dishwasher for easy cleaning. The non-stick coating will not flake and the pan will not warp when it is in the dishwasher.
Pros
Cons
10. LloydPans Kitchenware Pizza Pan
The LloydPans Kitchenware Pizza Pan is a sturdy piece of bakeware that is usually used in most pizzerias. The square-shaped pizza pan has a cooking surface area of 80 square inches and a depth of 2.25 inches. This means that you can use this pizza pan to make stuffed pizzas, meatloaves, pies or even brownies. The LloydPans Kitchenware Pizza Pan can be used to make a wide variety of meals.
The hard-anodized aluminium construction of the LloydPans Kitchenware Pizza Pan makes it more durable and long-lasting. The hard-anodized aluminium construction is said to conduct heat well.
The pizza pan will retain heat for longer periods of time and will spread out the heat evenly while it is in the oven. The hard-anodized aluminium also prevents the pizza pan from reacting with acidic food. This means that the flavour of your food will not be altered.
The spacious pizza pan has a non-stick coating which means that the pizza will not stick to the surface of the pan. This makes cleaning easier as you do not need to scrub the hardened bits of food off of the pan. Plus, the non-stick coating enables you to transfer the pizza onto another dish easily. The non-stick coating does not contain any PTFE which means that it is safe for consumption.
Pros
Cons
11. Legend Cast Iron Pizza Pan
The Legend Cast Iron brand produces one of the best pizza pans. The pizza pan has the shape of an egg. The inner diameter of the pizza pan is 13 inches but if you take in the raised ridges, then the total diameter stands at 14 inches.
This gives you a lot of space to cook a large pizza for a party with friends and family. You can also use the pan to cook omelettes, burger patties, strips of bacon and lots more.
The Legend Cast Iron Pizza Pan is made of alloy steel which means that the 14-inch pizza pan has a sturdy construction. It has the ability to retain heat well and the flat surface enables it to distribute heat evenly across the pan. Moreover, the alloy steel keeps the pizza pan from rusting or corroding so you know that it will serve you well for several years.
The pizza pan has a non-stick coating that makes it easy to slide the food onto another plate. It also makes cleaning easier. The non-stick coating is made from vegetable oil completely. It does not include any toxic chemicals or synthetic fibres so your health is not at risk.
You can use the cast iron on the grill or even over a campfire. It is suitable for use on multiple stovetops including gas, electric, glass or even induction stovetops. This allows for flexible cooking. Plus, the two tilted handles on each side enables you to lift the pan easily. The handles are large enough for you to hold them securely, even while wearing oven mitts or potholders.
You can easily clean the Legend Cast Iron Pizza Pan. It is recommended to wash the pizza pan with warm water and to dry it thoroughly before you store it. For maintenance, you need to coat it will oil and put the pan in the oven for 30 minutes at 450 degrees Fahrenheit. You need to do this a few times to enhance the seasoning process. This might be a lengthy process.
Pros
Cons
12. Beasea Pizza Pan
If you want the bottom of your pizza to be crispy and nice, the Beasea Pizza Pan might help. Since it has tiny holes in the pan, airflow is better so your pan heats up quickly and evenly. The round pan has a diameter of 8.5 inches and you will be able to prepare professional pizzas using it.
The Beasea Pizza Pan has a heavy-duty aluminium alloy construction that ensures durability. The aluminium alloy is 1.5mm thick. The pizza pan has a scratch-resistant coating all over the surface which means that you do not need to transfer the pizza onto another dish for cutting it into slices. Metal utensils or sharp objects will not affect the coating of the Beasea Pizza Pan.
The Beasea Pizza Pan has a high heat tolerance. It has the ability to function well in high temperatures and heats up quickly. Your pizza will not turn out to be soggy. On the other hand, the pizza pan is super easy to clean. All you need is a soft rag as hard cleaning tools may damage the coating on the surface of the pan.
Pros
Cons
Things To Consider Before Buying A Pizza Pan
Size
The size of your pizza pan will depend on the number of people you intend to feed. If you usually have a large gathering, you might want to invest in a pizza pan that is quite large. A large pizza pan will enable you to make a large pizza that you can cut into many slices. On the other hand, if you usually have a small group of friends or family over, then you might want a small pizza pan.
The size of your pizza pan will also depend on the size of your oven. If the pizza pan is too large for your oven, you might not be able to make pizzas using it. It is best to note down the measurements of the pizza pan and the capacity of your oven before making a decision.
The smallest pizza pan mentioned in this article is the Beasea Pizza Pan that has a diameter of 8.5 inches whereas the largest pizza pan mentioned in this article is the Heritage Pizza Pan
that has a diameter of 15 inches.
Shape
What type of shape you choose for your pizza pan will depend on your personal preference. Pizza pans usually come in two shapes that include a round shape and a square shape. Square pans usually have more depth compared to round pans. You can use square pans to make lasagna, pasta, meatloaves and many more. Pizza pans that have raised ridges allow you to cook stuffed pizzas or deep dishes.
Pizza pans that have a flat bottom are easier to set on oven racks or on the stovetop. Pizza pans that have holes on the surface allow for better air circulation which aids in cooking the pizza evenly.
Weight
Your pizza pan should be easy to carry. If it is too heavy, you might not be able to lift it with ease. A lightweight pizza pan will be easy to carry from one place to another, even if it has no handles.
Material
Your pizza pan should have a sturdy construction that will make it durable and long-lasting. Cast iron, aluminium or stainless steel pizza pans retain heat well. They also distribute heat evenly across the cooking surface. You should invest in a pizza pan that can withstand high temperatures so that it does not warp easily.
Pizza pans that come pre-seasoned save you a lot of time and effort as you do not need to go through the lengthy process of seasoning it. On the other hand, pizza pans that have a non-stick coating prevent food from sticking to the surface of the pan. The pizza will slide off easily and this will make cleaning easier.
Handles
Pizza pans that come with handles are much easier to carry compared to the pizza pans that do not come with handles. Make sure that the handles are large enough for you to hold, even while you are wearing oven mitts or potholders.
Cleaning And Maintenance
If the pizza pan has a non-stick coating, then it might be easier to clean as the crumbs or hardened remains of food will wash off quickly. When cleaning a pizza pan that has a non-stick coating, make sure to use mild soap and warm water.
On the other hand, if the pizza pan does not have a non-stick coating, you might want to soak the pan in soapy hot water to release the food that is stuck to the surface. You should not use hard brushes while cleaning the pan. You should always use a soft sponge to scrub off the crumbs.
Although some pizza pans are dishwasher-safe, it is recommended to wash the pans by hand as harsh dish detergents might damage the material. After you are done cleaning the pizza pan, make sure to dry the pan completely before storing it in a dry and cool place. You might want to lightly coat the pan with oil for added durability.
Conclusion
Pizzas are great for all occasions. You can make pizzas for a birthday party, a new year’s eve party or even for a casual hangout with friends and family. A slice or two of a tasty pizza will make anyone’s mood better. If you are eager to upgrade your pizza-making skills, you might want to consider investing in one of the best pizza pans and see the change yourself.