"We hope you love the products we recommend! When you buy through links on HeavenonSeven.com, We may earn an affiliate commission."

The 10 Best Store Bought Pizza Sauce Will Help to Make Restaurant Style Pizza At Home

Best Store Bought Pizza Sauce

Does your pizza sauce lack flavor? If the sauce is not good then the pizza would taste good. A great pizza sauce brings out a unique flavor and makes it appetizing. Adding the ingredients in the perfect ratio is essential to make the delicious sauce. On the other hand, a best store bought pizza sauce can help to make delicious pizza at home. 

The pizza sauce differs in consistency, taste, spice level, etc. usually the pizza sauces are not spicy and you have to add the peppers separately to the sauce. Moreover, if you have allergies or are lactose intolerant, make sure to check the ingredients list before buying a pizza sauce.


Best Pick

Don Pepino Pizza Sauce

The Don Pepino Pizza Sauce is our best pick on our list because the sauce does not have unhealthy fat, sugar, or cholesterol. This can of pizza sauce gives the taste of fresh vine ripened tomatoes. This sauce is fully prepared. You just need to spread on the crust, add some toppings, and heat in the oven before eating.

Budget Pick

Rao's Homemade Pizza Sauce

The Rao's Homemade Pizza Sauce is on our best budget pick because fresh onion and fresh carrots are included on the sauce ingredients list to make the taste different from others. This brand has 100% Italian tomatoes that fulfill the craving for traditional Italian pizza. Not to mention, the sauce is Whole 30 compliant.



1. Don Pepino Pizza Sauce

The sauce is an essential part to give flavors to pizza and for this Don Peponi has made sauces to make a delicious pizza. First of all the sauce is not spicy which can be served at family gatherings or birthday parties. The unique thing about their sauce is that it gives the aroma of traditional pizzas.   

Moreover, with this sauce, you can enjoy homemade pizza anytime you want. It comes in a tin can which is rich in taste and flavor. If you look at the contents, it has 5% sodium, 1% carb, and 3% fat. Only 3 grams of sugar is present and no cholesterol is added to the sauce. 

The ingredients of the sauce are organic so it has no chance of containing dairy. However, we are not sure if the nuts or grains are manufactured in the same facility as the sauce.

Pros

  • The sauce is made with fresh Jersey tomatoes.
  • Corn oil, garlic, and other spices give a new flavor to the sauce.
  • The sauce comes in a can that provides 7 servings.
  • It is a dairy-free pizza sauce with no other allergens.
  • The content of fat and cholesterol is very less in the sauce.
  • The sauce has the flavor of classic sauces that will be enjoyed by people of every age group.
  • The sauce is not spicy which will be loved by children.

Cons

  • The sauce is not spicy enough for spicy pizza lovers.
  • It is not certified as a kosher product though it has all vegan elements.

2. Rao's Homemade Pizza Sauce

Pizza sauce from Rao's Homemade gives the taste of homemade pizza sauce which contains lots of flavors. They have prepared their sauce with Italian peeled tomatoes and cherry tomatoes. Oregano, Olive oil, basil, garlic, and onions are added to add flavor to the sauce. The ingredients are slowly simmered at low temperatures to give out the aroma of each element. 

Moreover, the pizza contains 100% organic tomatoes. This sauce can be used to make low-carb pizzas. It has 0% cholesterol and 1% carbohydrate which can be eaten when you are on a diet. 

However, the brand has not mentioned if the pizza sauce contains any allergic contains like nuts, dairy, grains, etc. if you are not prone to any allergic reaction, this sauce would be the best jarred pizza sauce to buy for your homemade pizza.

Pros

  • Tomatoes sourced from Italy are peeled and processed to make the sauce.
  • The sauce has carrots, onion, oregano, garlic, and basil to enhance the flavor of the sauce.
  • It is a keto-friendly sauce that can be paired with traditional as well as cauliflower crust.
  • No additional sugar is used to prepare the sauce.
  • The sauce comes in a glass jar that can be reused after using the sauce.

Cons

  • The sauce needs to be refrigerated after opening.
  • The jar needs to be carefully handled as it is made of glass.

3. Ragu Pizza Sauce

With the pizza sauce from Ragu, you can enjoy restaurant style pizza at your home easily. The consistency of this pizza sauce is thicker than other sauces as it is prepared from tomato puree. The ingredients like salt, spices are added to the puree to enhance the flavor of the sauce. 

The pizza sauce has no additional colors, flavors, or high fructose corn syrup that can be harmful to health. The sauce is not spicy enough for spice lovers. You can add some spices while heating the sauce on the stove. 

Also, the sauce needs to be heated before spreading on the crust. Because the sauce is thick, check the taste of the sauce as too much addition of the sauce can ruin the taste of the pizza. Moreover, this sauce is not dairy-free and not keto-friendly.

Pros

  • The sauce is produced by adding soybean oil, salt, and species to tomato puree to create an intense flavor.
  • The sauce can be heated in the microwave or stove before adding to the crust.
  • One jar of pizza sauce is enough to give 6 servings.

Cons

  • The sauce needs to be used within five days of opening the jar.
  • Natural flavors are added to the sauce which can cause an allergic reaction.
  • The jar can be used to heat in the microwave.
  • It is not kosher certified or dairy-free.

4. Chef Boyardee Pizza Sauce

The cheesier the pizza is, the better it tastes, and adding the Chef Boyardee pizza sauce will take the taste to another level. The thing we like most about this sauce is that cheddar cheese is added to the sauce. Only 2% cheddar cheese is added to the sauce to give a different taste to the sauce.

On the other hand, water, tomato puree, modified corn starch spices, and salt are used in the sauce. The sauce contains milk which will not be suitable for those who cannot tolerate lactose. The sauce comes in a container that will need to be refrigerated after opening.  

For cheese lovers, this is a great pizza sauce and can be taken with other snacks as well. The sauce is not kosher certified but has an authentic rich flavor.

Pros

  • Cheese is added with Italian tomato to prepare this sauce
  • This pizza sauce can be added to a low-carb diet.
  • The added cheese on the sauce makes pizza delicious.
  • Can be served calzones, cheese sticks, etc.

Cons

  • The pizza sauce is not dairy-free.
  • A little amount of color is added to the sauce to enhance the look of the sauce.
  • The pizza might contain allergen elements.

5. Pastorelli Pizza Sauce

Pastorelli focuses on making a sauce that you can easily enjoy pizza at home on your weekends without much work. Different oils like canola oil and extra virgin oil are added for the flavors. Not to mention spices and garlic enhances the taste of the sauce. 

The best feature we like of this sauce is it has Pecorino Romano Cheese. The cheese is made of pasteurized sheep's milk. Those who don't like goat milk might not like the taste of this sauce. 

This is a can of 8 ounces of pizza sauce. The tin is made of BPA-free product which will not react with food if it comes in contact with heat. Though the sauce is gluten and preservative-free it contains lactose.

Pros

  • This is a cheese tomato sauce for pizza to give a rich zesty flavor.
  • Spices, garlic, canola oil, extra virgin oil, and salt are added to season the tomato puree.
  • The sauce is gluten-free and contains no preservatives.
  • It comes in a BPA-free tin to keep it healthy for customers.
  • The sauce has won an award for providing the best quality sauce.

Cons

  • The pizza sauce contains milk, making it not suitable for everyone.
  • The can should be refrigerated if the whole amount of sauce is not used.

6. Muir Glen Pizza Sauce

Muir Glen prepares their pizza sauces with the organic tomatoes grown in the San Joaquin Valley of California. The tomatoes are harvested when they are ripened enough to use for pizza sauce. These organic tomatoes are processed within the 8 hours of harvesting to lock the real flavors of the tomatoes. 

In addition, the sauce is USDA certified and the tomatoes are grown organically which certified them as a non-GMO project. To make the sauce spicier, black pepper is used in the sauce. Garlic, basil, oregano, sea salt, olive oil are the common ingredients to season the sauce. 

Though it contains no allergen components, it is not verified as an allergic-free sauce. The sauce has no certification from the kosher community as well. The tin of the sauce can be hard to open if you do not have a tin opener. If you did not use the whole sauce, make sure to refrigerate it.

Pros

  • It is a thick pizza sauce made from Californian tomatoes.
  • Dehydrated onion, extra virgin olive oil, oregano, basil, etc are added to the sauce.
  • The sauce has no cholesterol or trans fat that is unhealthy.
  • Tomato soups, stews can be made with this pizza sauce.
  • The pizza sauce is verified as a USDA organic and non-GMO project.
  • This gluten-free sauce comes in a BPA-free can.

Cons

  • The sauce has to be refrigerated once unsealed.

7. Contadina Pizza Sauce

Contadina prepares their pizza sauces in Roma style. The sauce has a thicker consistency than other brands. Modified corn starch, soybean oil, onions, garlic makes the tomato puree flavorful. Aside from pizza, this sauce can be used on toasted English muffins or bagels, snack crackers, pasta, etc.

It comes in a squeeze bottle that makes it easier to take the sauce out. The feature we like about this pizza sauce is that you can take the bottle easily with you to enjoy snacks with sauce on a trip.

However, the sauce has preservatives that can be bad for health. It needs to be stored in the freezer once the lid is open. The sauce is flavorful but not spicy. You can add peppers after spreading the sauce on the pizza crust.

Pros

  • The pizza sauce is versatile to use for all types of snacks.
  • Spices, garlic, onion, corn starch are put together to make the sauce.
  • The sauce is kosher certified to serve a wide group of people.
  • It comes in an easy to pour and store bottle.
  • The sauce has no cholesterol and fat which is good for health.

Cons

  • The plastic bottle on which the sauce comes in is not BPA-free.
  • Might contain some ingredients that can cause allergies.

8. Botticelli Pizza Sauce

The cherry tomatoes are collected from Parma city in Italy to bake pizzas at home using this sauce easily. The sauce is prepared using the recipe of traditional pizza sauce. Various flavourful ingredients like basil, oregano, onion, garlic, extra virgin olive oil are used to kick the taste of the pizza. 

This jarred sauce has low carbohydrates and no added sugar. People of all ages can enjoy this sauce on pizzas. You need to heat the sauce before spreading or the cheese won't easily melt on the pizza. 

Each sauce jar contains 350 grams of sauce that can be used on 4 to 5 pizzas. The lid is a product of tin. The jar needs to be handled carefully as it is made of glass. The sauce is not gluten-free nor kosher-certified.

Pros

  • This sauce is a product of freshly collected Italian tomatoes.
  • It gives a traditional Italian taste to the pizza.
  • Online, garlic, olive oil, carrots bring out the authentic flavor of the sauce.
  • This gluten-free pizza sauce is a product of Italy.
  • The sauce is sold in a glass jar that can be reused.

Cons

  • The brand has not mentioned any allergen information.

9. Godfather's Pizza Sauce

Getting the restaurant style at home is not easy because the homemade sauce doesn't taste as good as the restaurant ones. Godfather brings the restaurant style pizzas sauce to enjoy mouth-watering pizza at home. The sauce is flavorful with the ingredients like oregano, spices, garlic powder, etc. 

The sauce has no cholesterol, fat, or sugar. As a result, this pizza sauce can be enjoyed by everyone. The brand has been creating the sauce for over 43 years which helps to make perfect Italian dishes. 

Heating the sauce before spreading is recommended or the taste of the sauce will be dull. It has no non-GMO or kosher certification. The sauce can contain elements that can lead to an allergic reaction.

Pros

  • This sauce gives the taste of restaurant style pizzas at home.
  • Regular ingredients like oregano, basil, and garlic are used to make delicious pizza sauce.
  • It can be used as a dipping sauce with different snacks.
  • The sauce has no overpowering flavor and gives a perfect taste to the pizza.

Cons

  • The sauce is not spicy enough.
  • The sauce is not keto or any diet-friendly.

10. Stanislaus Pizza Sauce

Lastly, we have the pizza sauce from Stanislaus. This is a ready-made pizza sauce to enjoy with pizzas, pasta, or other dishes. This canned sauce is made from freshly picked tomatoes and added with ingredients to make it delicious. 

The sauce needs to be kept in the freezer after opening it. The sauce is more on the spicier side than on the sweet tangy taste. For the spice lover, this can be the best store bought pizza sauce. 

Not to mention, the pizza sauce is certified as kosher. Though we are not sure if it's a non-GMO or dairy-free product.

Pros

  • Superior quality tomatoes are collected to use on this tomato sauce.
  • This pizza sauce can be used as tomato sauce on different dishes.
  • Black pepper is used in the sauce to make it spicy.
  • The sauce blends well with different types of snacks as well.

Cons

  • Heating is required before serving the sauce.
  • The sauce is thick and needs to add the water for use in tomato soups or curries.

Things To Consider Before Buying The Best Store Bought Pizza Sauce

Do your pizzas not taste as good as the restaurant ones? Perfecting in the pizza sauce takes a lot of perseverance. But you can buy a pizza sauce for now to enjoy the deliciousness of pizza at home.

Ingredients on the pizza sauce

Tomato is the key ingredient of the pizza sauce. After collecting the tomatoes, they are turned into a puree. In that puree, salt, oregano, garlic, species, etc are added to enhance the flavor of the sauce. Sauce without garlic, oregano, and salt would be tasteless.

To create variation in the flavors of the sauce, brands add some other elements as well. You will see carrots and onions are being added to the sauce. These two ingredients increase the thickness as well as make it taste slightly different from the original pizza sauce. 

In addition, soybean oil and extra virgin olive oil are used to cook the sauce. The olive oil increases the traditional flavor of the pizza sauce.  

The spice level of the sauce

Different people have different preferences when it comes to spice levels. Children would want a pizza with a mild spice flavor. On the other hand, a group of people might want a spicy sauce on the pizza. That's why chili flakes are given with the sauce. 

Nowadays, brands are making ready to use sauces where you do not need to add spices separately. Black peppers are added for the spiciness of the sauce. 

With cheese or without the cheese

Adding cheese is a new thing brands are including in their sauces. Those who love pizza tend to be fans of cheese. To make it more cheese, cheese is added to the sauce. The sauce can taste salty if tasted alone. But with crust and toppings, they taste delicious. 

Moreover, if you have less amount of cheese at home, the pizza with cheese will fulfill the lacking taste of cheese on the pizza. Those who are lactose intolerant cannot have the sauce in their pizza. It is better to ask your guest if they can eat cheesy pizza sauce.

Canned or jarred pizza sauce

The pizza sauces are packaged in cans or glass jars. Cans are not reusable whereas the glass jars can be recycled until it's broken. It is up to you to decide on which type of packaged sauce you want. 

We also mentioned a pizza sauce on a squeeze bottle in our article. Squeeze bottles are easy to pour the sauces. However, check if the package is BPA-free or environmentally friendly. 

The expiration date of the sauce

No sauces should be bought without checking the expiration date. The pizza sauce has preservatives to keep them in good condition. But the preservatives won't keep them good when the expiration date is passed. Purchase the pizza with a longer duration on the expiry date if you do not have pizza regularly. 

One important thing to mention, the sauce should be finished after a few days of opening the lid. Keeping in the freezer after opening will not keep the sauce in good condition for a long time.

Allergen information

Cheese, soy, garlic, etc, ingredients are commonly used in the sauce. Brands not only produce pizza sauce but also other products as well. If they are also packaging grans, nuts on the same premises as the sauce, the dust of the grans can get mixed with the sauce. 

The brands mention if they have dairy or gluten or grains in their sauce so that their customers do not have to suffer from eating their sauce. 

Diet-friendly

For healthy living, having an ideal diet is necessary. If you are doing a keto or paleo or vegan diet, you might not want to have pizzas. But sometimes, pizza craving makes it harder to diet. This low-carb, keto-friendly pizza sauce is also found in the shops. You just need to check on the details on the body of the sauce to find the right pizza sauce. 

FAQ

Are tomato sauce and tomato puree the same thing?

No, they are not the same thing. Tomato puree has a thick consistency compared to tomato sauce.

Can I add my own ingredients to the sauce to make it distinct?

Yes, you can add spices according to your taste in the sauce. 

Conclusion

If you have bought the pizza sauce, you need to store it in a cool place. Pizza stays good for a long period if the seal remains unopened. Also, many brands recommend finishing the sauce within 5 days of opening the jar. 

Moreover, if you don't like the taste of the pizza, you add some ingredients to change the taste. We advise increasing the spiciness as we found the spice level of the pizza sauces is mild. Check the dietary and allergen information of the sauces before choosing the best store bought pizza sauce for your homemade pizza.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top